Twenty dead rockhopper chicks examined after a storm on New Island in the Falklands had stomachs full of fresh food.1 Their parents had brought them meals. Cold rain had soaked their down before they had grown waterproof plumage.
On 10 January 2008, 120 mm of rain fell in 24 hours—nearly a fifth of the island’s 634 mm total for the previous year. Low temperatures and a hard southerly wind hit Western Rockhopper colonies as month-old chicks were gathering in crèches beyond their parents’ direct cover. In one sub-colony on open rock, the event killed 68.2 per cent of chicks that had been alive on 1 January.1
Breeding success for the season fell to 0.49 chicks per nest, down from an expected 0.66 and the previous season’s 0.69.1 The post-mortems explained a loss that a count of fledglings alone could have mistaken for food failure.
A bad breeding year is easy to misdiagnose from a final headcount. Depending on the species and the site, mass mortality can come from a sudden soaking before waterproof plumage develops, a multi-month winter fast that lasts a few days too long, or sea ice breaking up before chicks can swim. And before any of those seasonal disasters can be measured, biologists have to account for the baseline losses that happen in perfectly ordinary years.
Exposure, Shelter, and the Crèche Window
Whether a storm kills chicks depends heavily on where they are sitting and how old they are when it arrives. At New Island, the authors reported roughly three times as many deaths across the January 2008 rain events in the bare rocky sub-colony than in a neighbouring sub-colony fringed with tussac grass.1 Grazing and burning have stripped tussac across much of the Falklands since the nineteenth century, removing the windbreak and overhead cover that once buffered chicks from southerly squalls.
The calendar matters just as much as the terrain. Falklands rockhoppers follow a tight seasonal schedule:
- Laying: highly synchronised, from 27 October to 10 November at New Island.
- Hatching: 2 to 15 December.
- Guard stage: the male holds the nest and fasts for 20 to 28 days while the female returns with food most afternoons.
- Crèche: beginning in late December, when both parents forage at sea.
- Moult into waterproof juvenile plumage: 35 to 40 days of age.
- Fledging: around ten weeks.1
The early crèche period leaves rockhopper chicks particularly exposed to wet weather. Once a chick grows too large for one parent to brood it while the other hunts, both adults must go to sea at the same time to meet its caloric needs. The chick is out from under an adult coat, but it has not yet completed the moult into waterproof juvenile feathers. Wet down loses its insulating air layer, chilling even a well-fed bird.
Even without a catastrophic storm, losses cluster in the early stages of the season. At Gough Island, researchers tracking Northern Rockhoppers found that brood loss was heaviest during incubation and the early chick stage, claiming 33 to 61 per cent of attempts. Of the chicks that hatched, 71 per cent survived to enter a crèche, and 73 per cent of those present at early crèche finished their moult into juvenile plumage.2
That Gough Island study also showed how social structure protects nests. Breeding success rose with two local factors: how vigorously breeding adults responded to threats, and how many other breeding birds sat within 1.5 metres.2 Colony density provides mutual defence, which means a declining colony can become less effective at protecting its remaining chicks as its ranks thin out.
When Parents Buffer the Ocean—and When They Cannot
When conditions change at sea, chick deaths are rarely the first thing to show up in the data. Adult penguins absorb substantial marine variation by working harder before their chicks ever miss a meal.
Dehnhard and colleagues tracked chick-rearing rockhoppers at New Island across two seasons that differed in sea surface temperature, chlorophyll a, foraging distance, dive depth, and diet—crustacean-dominated in one year, and a mixture of squid and fish in the next. Despite those shifts in ocean conditions and foraging effort, chick growth rates and chick survival showed no matching difference between the two seasons, and the authors could not identify a better year for the chicks; they also cautioned that both seasons may have been relatively favourable.3
These observations show that changed ocean conditions need not immediately reduce chick survival. How far parents can adjust, and how much delay chicks can tolerate, varies with the species and breeding stage. Across different penguin lineages, that breaking point takes very different forms.
Starvation on a slow winter clock
King Penguin chicks do not fledge in a single summer. They overwinter in the colony and are fed only irregularly over the cold months. Cherel and Le Maho followed captive king chicks that entered their winter fast at an average mass near 12.5 kg and fasted for an average of five months, dropping to 4.0 kg—a 68 per cent loss of body mass.4 The authors separately noted starvation deaths around 3.0 kg in chicks whose parents were delayed returning to the colony; that figure is not a universal threshold for every chick.4 For a king penguin, a bad year is a slow depletion of lipid and protein reserves over months rather than a single afternoon storm.
Sea ice breakup under the colony
For Emperor Penguins, the ground itself can disappear before the chicks are ready for the water. In the Bellingshausen Sea in 2022, land-fast sea ice broke up before chicks had grown waterproof plumage; out of five breeding sites in the region, four experienced total breeding failure.5 It was the first widespread emperor breeding failure clearly attributable to large-scale sea ice contraction, and that vulnerability contributed directly to the species being uplisted to Endangered on 9 April 2026.6
Rain and blocked foraging lanes
Sometimes weather and ice combine to hit both ends of the provisioning loop at once. Adélie Penguins in Terre Adélie experienced a complete breeding failure in the 2013/14 season, fledging no chicks at all. Unusually heavy precipitation soaked and killed chicks at the nest, while weak katabatic winds failed to blow sea ice away from the coast, leaving an extensive ice sheet pinned around the colony that stretched every adult foraging trip.7 Over a longer timeframe—23 seasons near Palmer Station—Adélie chick fledging mass tracked large-scale climate and local weather more strongly than it tracked shifts in parental diet.8
The Baseline: Brood Reduction in Ordinary Years
To tell whether any of these pressures have caused an abnormal die-off, researchers first have to subtract the eggs and chicks that die in every normal season. Nowhere is that baseline more lopsided than in the crested penguins—the genus Eudyptes, which includes the rockhoppers, Macaroni, Royal, Erect-crested, Fiordland, and Snares penguins.
Crested penguins lay a two-egg clutch in which the first-laid A-egg is smaller than the second-laid B-egg by 17.5 to 56.9 per cent, depending on the species—the most extreme intraclutch egg-size dimorphism documented in birds.9 The hatching order then reverses the laying order: the larger B-egg hatches first, sometimes up to three days earlier than the A-egg.10 If the A-egg hatches at all, its chick emerges smaller and later into a nest where its sibling already has a head start.
Across the genus, fewer than 1 per cent of A-eggs produce a fledged chick, and pairs almost never fledge two chicks.9 At Marion Island, Williams tracked macaroni and rockhopper nests through a full season and found that most of this reduction happens before hatching—egg mortality exceeded chick mortality in both species.11
| Measure (Marion Island season) | Rockhopper | Macaroni |
|---|---|---|
| Nests where both eggs hatched | 6 per cent | None |
| A-egg mortality | 88 per cent | 99.7 per cent |
| B-egg mortality | 32 per cent | 44 per cent |
| Pairs rearing two chicks | None | None |
In the 6 per cent of rockhopper nests where both eggs hatched, one of the two chicks starved within twelve days.11
In several crested species, the A-egg does not even stay in the nest long enough to be incubated. In Royal Penguins, St Clair and colleagues observed that the overwhelming cause of A-egg loss was ejection from the nest by the female around the time the B-egg was laid.12 Erect-crested Penguins show an equally stark pattern. At the Antipodes Islands in 1998, Davis and colleagues recorded a 5.4-day laying interval—the longest known for any penguin—and found that 42.3 per cent of A-eggs were lost before the B-egg was even laid, another 37.8 per cent disappeared on the day the B-egg arrived, and none survived more than seven days afterward.13 Some 91.2 per cent of those nests contained no nesting material, with eggs laid directly onto bare rock where A-eggs were lost mainly by rolling out. When the researchers experimentally installed barriers to keep the A-eggs from rolling out of the nest, the retained A-eggs still survived no longer than the unmanipulated controls.13 In that studied population, brood reduction is obligate rather than an adjustment to scarce food.
Why lay an egg that almost never survives?
Why crested penguins continue to produce a disposable first egg remains an open question in seabird biology. In 1998, St Clair outlined several hypotheses that have still largely gone untested: the A-egg might signal to neighbours that a nest site is occupied, reducing territorial fights; act as a visual stimulus that tightens laying synchrony across the colony; advertise a female's reproductive readiness to a young or first-time mate; or supply tactile stimulation that initiates brood-patch development, warming the nest in advance for the B-egg.14
Other researchers argue that the trait does not need a current adaptive benefit to persist. Stein and Williams proposed in 2013 that the two-egg clutch in Eudyptes is a genus-wide evolutionary lag—a retained ancestral trait rather than an active insurance strategy. Compared with other penguins that lay two eggs, Eudyptes species first breed 52 per cent later, have 48 per cent lower annual fecundity, and fledge 43 per cent fewer chicks per clutch, yet have retained the two-egg clutch alongside a slow, pelagic life history.9 Crossin and colleagues identified the physiological constraint behind the size gap: females begin egg formation while still migrating back to the colony, arriving in a state of low reproductive readiness that limits how much resource reaches the first developing follicle.15 The A-egg may simply be small because it begins forming while the female is still swimming home.
Why Long-Term Colony Declines Are Hard to Forecast
Understanding what killed chicks in a single season still does not tell conservationists which colonies will collapse over a decade. Because nest substrate, colony density, and localized squalls can wipe out an exposed sub-colony while sparing birds behind tussac grass a short walk away, regional climate averages often miss the local hazards that actually kill chicks.
Movement between sites complicates the picture further. Southern rockhoppers are highly vagile and have been modelled as a metapopulation, meaning that a headland where breeding numbers drop has not necessarily lost all of its birds to mortality; some individuals may relocate.16 And even when a season goes well enough to put fledglings in the water, the final outcome takes years to appear. Fledging mass is a strong predictor of whether a young bird will survive at sea and recruit into the breeding population, but a rockhopper does not return to breed for about four years.10 Whether a rough season merely dented a single cohort or weakened the colony's future breeding stock stays hidden until those survivors come ashore.
References
-
Demongin, L., Poisbleau, M., Strange, I.J. & Quillfeldt, P. (2010). Effects of severe rains on the mortality of Southern Rockhopper Penguin (Eudyptes chrysocome) chicks and its impact on breeding success. Ornitología Neotropical 21: 439–443. https://digitalcommons.usf.edu/ornitologia_neotropical/vol21/iss3/11 ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5
-
Wilson, J.W., Burle, M.-H., Cuthbert, R., Stirnemann, R.L. & Ryan, P.G. (2010). Breeding success of Northern Rockhopper Penguins (Eudyptes moseleyi) at Gough Island, South Atlantic Ocean. Emu 110: 137–141. https://doi.org/10.1071/MU09095 ↩ ↩2
-
Dehnhard, N., Ludynia, K., Masello, J.F., Voigt, C.C., McGill, R.A.R. & Quillfeldt, P. (2016). Plasticity in foraging behaviour and diet buffers effects of inter-annual environmental differences on chick growth and survival in southern rockhopper penguins Eudyptes chrysocome chrysocome. Polar Biology 39: 1627–1641. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00300-015-1887-5 ↩
-
Cherel, Y. & Le Maho, Y. (1985). Five months of fasting in king penguin chicks: body mass loss and fuel metabolism. American Journal of Physiology 249: R387–R392. https://doi.org/10.1152/ajpregu.1985.249.4.R387 ↩ ↩2
-
Fretwell, P.T., Boutet, A. & Ratcliffe, N. (2023). Record low 2022 Antarctic sea ice led to catastrophic breeding failure of emperor penguins. Communications Earth & Environment 4: 273. https://doi.org/10.1038/s43247-023-00927-x ↩
-
IUCN (9 April 2026). Emperor penguin and Antarctic fur seal now Endangered due to climate change – IUCN Red List. Press release. https://iucn.org/press-release/202604/emperor-penguin-and-antarctic-fur-seal-now-endangered-due-climate-change-iucn ↩
-
Ropert-Coudert, Y. et al. (2015). A complete breeding failure in an Adélie penguin colony correlates with unusual and extreme environmental events. Ecography 38: 111–113. https://doi.org/10.1111/ecog.01182 ↩
-
Cimino, M.A., Fraser, W.R., Patterson-Fraser, D.L., Saba, V.S. & Oliver, M.J. (2014). Large-scale climate and local weather drive interannual variability in Adélie penguin chick fledging mass. Marine Ecology Progress Series 513: 253–268. https://lternet.edu/biblio/large-scale-climate-and-local-weather-drive-interannual-variability-in-adalie-penguin-chick-fledging-mass/ ↩
-
Stein, R.W. & Williams, T.D. (2013). Extreme intraclutch egg-size dimorphism in Eudyptes penguins, an evolutionary response to clutch-size maladaptation. The American Naturalist 182: 260–270. https://www.sfu.ca/biology/wildberg/NewCWEPage/papers/SteinWilliamsAmNat2013.pdf ↩ ↩2 ↩3
-
Katz, C. (2026). Rockhopper penguins' athleticism makes them the daredevils of the animal world. Will a warming climate slow them down?. Smithsonian Magazine, January–February 2026; republished by bioGraphic. https://www.biographic.com/can-rockhoppers-survive-the-next-leap/ ↩ ↩2
-
Williams, A.J. (1980). Offspring reduction in macaroni and rockhopper penguins. The Auk 97: 754–759. https://digitalcommons.usf.edu/auk/vol97/iss4/11 ↩ ↩2
-
St Clair, C.C., Waas, J.R., St Clair, R.C. & Boag, P.T. (1995). Unfit mothers? Maternal infanticide in royal penguins. Animal Behaviour 50: 1177–1185. https://doi.org/10.1016/0003-3472(95)80034-4 ↩
-
Davis, L.S., Renner, M., Houston, D., Zhu, L., Finkler, W. & Mattern, T. (2022). The breeding biology of erect-crested penguins, Eudyptes sclateri: hormones, behavior, obligate brood reduction and conservation. PLoS ONE 17(10): e0275106. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0275106 ↩ ↩2
-
St Clair, C.C. (1998). What is the function of first eggs in crested penguins?. The Auk 115: 478–482. https://digitalcommons.usf.edu/auk/vol115/iss2/25 ↩
-
Crossin, G.T., Trathan, P.N., Phillips, R.A., Dawson, A., Le Bouard, F. & Williams, T.D. (2010). A carryover effect of migration underlies individual variation in reproductive readiness and extreme egg size dimorphism in macaroni penguins. The American Naturalist 176: 357–366. https://www.sfu.ca/biology/wildberg/NewCWEPage/papers/CrossinetalAmNat2010.pdf ↩
-
Lois, N.A. et al. (2020). Metapopulation dynamics and foraging plasticity in a highly vagile seabird, the southern rockhopper penguin. Ecology and Evolution 10: 3346–3355. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7141044/ ↩



